Freight Agent Vs Freight Broker

March 27, 2025

Freight Agent Vs Freight Broker: Key Differences

The logistics sector relies heavily on freight brokers and agents. While both contribute to the transportation of goods, their roles differ in terms of authority and responsibility.

To help you decide between these two careers, we’ll examine their fundamental differences, including responsibilities and operations. We’ll also compare the pros and cons of each career path, explore their earning potential, and provide practical steps for getting started.

By the end, you’ll be able to make a well-informed decision that aligns with your personal career objectives and circumstances.

What Is A Freight Broker?

A freight broker is an authorized person or business who holds their own operating authority granted by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA). They arrange deals between shippers (who have goods that need to be transported) and carriers (who have trucks, ships, or planes to move goods).

Freight brokers play a crucial role in the supply chain by streamlining the logistics industry, improving cost efficiency, and providing flexibility.

Responsibilities of a freight broker

Freight brokers must be registered and licensed with the FMCSA. They have several responsibilities in the logistics industry that ensure smooth operations between shippers and carriers.

Their responsibilities include:

Negotiate rates: They negotiate competitive freight rates with carriers while ensuring a fair price for shippers.
Handle logistics and coordination: Brokers manage the scheduling, routing, and tracking of shipments.
Provide risk management and compliance: Brokers ensure that all parties involved comply with industry permits, regulations, and insurance requirements.
Manage payments: By facilitating the transactions between shippers and carriers, brokers ensure timely payments and reduce financial risks.

Pros and cons of becoming a freight broker

✅ Pros	❌ Cons
Unlimited earning potential: The more you work, the more you earn.	Regulatory requirements: Freight brokers must obtain an FMCSA license and a $75,000 surety bond.
No assets or inventory needed: Brokers don’t own or maintain fleets, like trucking companies, resulting in reduced overhead costs.	Inconsistent income: New brokers or slow shipping seasons may produce inconsistent earnings. However, this is less likely with seasoned brokers.
Scalability and flexibility: Freight brokers can easily scale their operations, work from anywhere, and have somewhat flexible schedules.	Competitive industry: High demand for freight brokers has produced a saturated industry.
	Fast-paced: Freight brokers may experience stressful periods when maintaining multiple shipments, negotiating rates, and resolving logistical issues.

Despite the challenges, becoming a freight broker can be a profitable and flexible career. If you have strong sales, negotiating, and networking skills, consider completing our 90-Day Freight Broker training program.

What Is A Freight Agent?

Freight agents, also known as sales agents, work as independent contractors under the authority of a freight broker. They are responsible for matching shippers with the appropriate carriers, resolving any issues or shipment delays that may arise, and acting as a point of contact for clients.

Agents don’t have a freight broker’s operating license and aren’t held legally liable for freight or the handling of financial transactions.

Freight agents also earn a salary and commissions on deals they’ve arranged. The brokerage they work for usually agrees on a base salary supplemented with performance bonuses or commissions.

Responsibilities of a freight agent

The responsibilities of freight agents include:

Find and secure clients: Freight agents identify and maintain relationships with shippers by providing logistics solutions.
Match loads with carriers: They work with broker networks, load boards, and industry connections to match loads with carriers.
Track shipments: Freight agents provide shippers with freight updates and handle logistical challenges, ensuring smooth shipments.
Build industry relationships: They work toward building strong customer relationships, customer satisfaction, and client retention.

Pros and cons of becoming a freight agent

✅ Pros	❌ Cons
Low startup costs: Unlike freight brokers, sales agents don’t need FMCSA operating authority, licensing, or surety bonds to get started.	Dependence on brokers: Freight agents typically work for freight brokers and depend on them for operations, pricing, and carrier selection.
Stable earning potential: The more shipping loads freight agents can book, the more they earn. Additionally, freight agents can expect a stable income.	Competitive industry: The freight industry is crowded, and it can be difficult for new agents to establish themselves.
No asset management: Freight agents don’t own any assets.	High sales pressure: Freight agents need strong sales and negotiating skills to thrive in the industry.
Growth opportunities: Freight agents can transition into becoming freight brokers and run a successful freight brokerage.	No direct control over carriers: If carrier challenges arise, like late deliveries or damages, freight agents need to handle customer complaints without having direct control over the situation.

Key Differences Between A Freight Agent And A Freight Broker

Let’s take a look at the key differences between freight agents versus freight brokers.

Factor	Freight Agent	Freight Broker
Handle’s cargo?	No (only matches shippers with carriers)	No (only facilitates transport)
Provides insurance?	No	No
Storage & Warehousing?	No	No
Regulatory Requirements	No (don’t have operating authority)	Higher (brokerage authority and compliance required)
Startup Costs	Low (work as independent contractors)	Higher (licensing, surety bond, and insurance)
Profit Potential	Lower (earn agreed salary/commission % with brokerage firm)	Higher (direct control over profit margin)
Business Model	Work as an independent freight agent	Non-asset based

How To Get Started As A Freight Broker Or Freight Agent

Since no formal qualifications are necessary, getting started as a freight broker or freight agent is pretty straightforward. However, the process differs slightly for each career path:

Freight brokers

Freight brokers must first understand the freight and logistics industry, including terminology, regulations, and pricing strategies. Not only will this improve their credibility, but also give them the skills to build strong networks with shippers and carriers.

They must also:

Apply to the FMCSA for an operating license.
Secure a $75,000 bond.
Register their business with their local secretary of state.

Once completed, these professionals can run a freight broker business and build a carrier and shipper network.

Freight agents

This is a much faster and cheaper career path. Similarly, freight agents must learn and understand the freight and logistics industry.

They then need to find well-known freight brokers to work with before they can build relationships with shippers and carriers, book shipments, and earn commissions.

However, getting started as a freight agent on your own can be tricky. That’s why it’s highly recommended that you complete our 90-Day Freight Agent course. Our program provides expert advice and tips and gives you the competitive advantage needed to thrive in this industry.

Freight Broker Vs Freight Agent: Career Outlook

The freight broker market is expected to grow from $51.7 billion in 2023 to $85.9 billion by 2032. This expansion is due to growing e-commerce and global trade, increasing the demand for both freight brokers and freight agents.

Additionally, technological advancements and evolving market demands offer exciting industry opportunities for freight brokers and agents who remain resilient and adaptive.

With the right skills and knowledge of this industry, both career outlooks are favorable, with many growth opportunities.

Freight broker salary

Freight broker salaries are made up of base pay and commissions. The average base pay for freight brokers in 2023 was $52,460 annually, with brokers in higher percentiles earning over $70,000 annually.

Additionally, they can earn 15% to 18% commission of their gross profit margin for each freight brokerage operation. This means they can earn an estimated commission between $45,000 and $55,000 annually.

Freight agent salary

Freight agents earn a salary from their brokerages, as well as additional commission. Freight brokerages usually agree on a standard base salary and supplement it with the opportunity to earn commissions.

Freight agents earn an average of $47,600 annually, with agents in higher percentiles earning just under $70,000 annually. That’s around $25 an hour, or $4,000 a month.

Commission rates depend on agreements with the brokerage, market conditions, as well as the agent’s experience and customer base.

FAQs

1. Is it better to be a freight broker or agent?

This depends on your goals and preferences. Freight brokers have more autonomy and higher earning potential. However, becoming a freight agent would be more suitable if you don’t want to run your own business.

2. How do freight agents make money?

Freight agents earn money from their brokerage via an agreed-upon salary. They also earn a commission.

Final Thoughts

Choosing between becoming a freight broker or a freight agent is a significant career decision, each offering advantages.

Freight brokers enjoy an unlimited earning potential, flexible schedules, and the ability to run their brokerage. On the other hand, freight agents enjoy income stability, low startup costs, and the opportunity to transition into becoming a freight broker.

If you have an entrepreneurial mindset and the budget to obtain your authority and licensing, becoming a freight broker may be the right path. However, if you prefer a lower-risk entry into the industry, starting as a freight agent is a great option.

If you’re still unsure, consider enrolling in our comprehensive 90-Day Freight Broker and Freight Agent training program. Get insights from industry experts and learn at your own pace, whether with audio, video, or text.

Sources: