Freight Broker Prospecting Tips

April 23, 2025

Freight Broker Prospecting Tips

Prospecting is one of the hardest parts of the freight sales process. Whether you’re considering becoming a broker or have some experience in the industry, it’s hard to work out the best approach. Yet, getting it right is the key to consistent growth.

We created this guide to help brokers of all experience levels connect with the right prospects and win more loads. We’ll explore why prospecting matters, share 10 actionable tips, and highlight mistakes to avoid, so let’s get right into it.

Why Is Prospecting Important for Freight Brokers?

Prospecting is the first step in building relationships with new clients. It involves identifying, researching, and contacting shippers who might need your services.

This process is important because it ensures a steady stream of new leads flowing into your freight brokerage business. So, even if contracts end or markets shift, you’ll always have new potential clients ready to fill any gaps.

However, prospecting isn’t just important for immediate freight sales. It also helps you build long-term visibility. For instance, even if a new prospect doesn’t convert at first, you’ll be top of mind when they require freight services in the future.

How to Prospect as a Freight Broker: Top 10 Tips

Now that you know why prospecting is such an important part of the freight sales process, here are 10 proven tips to help you connect with shippers and grow your business.

1. Get into the prospecting mindset

Before you start actively prospecting, you need to get into the right mindset. This means approaching each outreach with purpose rather than treating prospecting as a numbers game. The aim isn’t just to sell your services but also qualify shippers.

To qualify shippers, you need to determine if a potential client is the right fit for your services and if you can offer long-term value. Don’t be afraid to rule out prospects if you can’t give them what they need, and be prepared to hear “no” from potential clients.

Developing a growth mindset means being persistent without becoming pushy and treating rejection as part of the process.

2. Identify your ideal shipper profile

The freight industry is broad and varied. As such, there are freight brokers that specialize in every imaginable niche.

Before you start prospecting, you need to determine which niches you’ll specialize in and clearly define your ideal shipper. Otherwise, you’ll be blindly prospecting, which leads to wasted time and mismatched expectations.

You may already know which niche you want to work in, but if not, consider which aspects of freight brokering interest you the most and the unique skills you bring to the table. For example, you could specialize in:

Temperature-controlled loads for food and beverage companies.
Dry van freight in the southeast.
High-volume lanes from Chicago to Dallas.

Once you’ve determined your niche or niches, it’s time to build out an ideal shipper persona. To do this, consider things like:

Industry (manufacturing, retail, ecommerce, etc.).
Freight type (FTL, LTL, flatbed, etc.).
Volume and frequency of shipments.
Seasonality and lead times.

Your ideal shipper profile allows you to tailor your prospecting messaging and spend time on the leads who are most likely to use your services.

3. Research before you reach out

Before reaching out to potential shippers, you need to do your research. This means taking the time to understand their business, common pain points, and supply chain needs. The easiest ways to research shippers include:

Company websites: Look for valuable insights about vendors, shipping methods, and logistics contacts.
LinkedIn: Find information about their industry, company size, and decision-makers.
Google Maps: Take a look at their facilities and determine whether they’re in a warehouse district, near major highways, and other useful information.

Even basic research demonstrates to shippers that you’re genuinely interested in their specific business and unique requirements. It enables you to discuss things like freight challenges in their niche and current industry trends, which instantly increases your credibility.

4. Build and organize a prospecting list

Being organized is the best way to prospect as a freight broker. No matter how good your messaging is or how much industry knowledge you have, disorganization leads to poor outcomes.

So, you’ll need to build a list of prospects by using:

Industry directories such as the DAT directory.
LinkedIn and other business networking sites.
Trade show exhibitor lists.
Existing customer referrals.
Cold outreach on platforms like Apollo.io.

Once you have your list, you need to organize it in a spreadsheet. Or, even better, you can use a CRM system to track data like:

Outreach dates.
Contact info and decision-maker name.
Follow-up reminders.
Notes on calls and emails.

To run more targeted prospecting campaigns, you should segment your list by industry, region, and freight type. This ensures you prospect efficiently and stops you from missing any follow-ups.

5. Utilize cold calling and cold emailing

Although prospecting has evolved in recent years, cold calling and emailing are still important. However, generic outreach simply won’t cut it. Here are some tips for success:

Cold calling tips

Always do your homework and never call blindly.
Start with a confident and respectful opener, like: “Hi [Name], I noticed your company ships out of [location]. Do you manage the freight there?”.
Respond to any objections with curiosity rather than defensiveness.
Don’t launch straight into a sales pitch. Instead, focus on asking smart questions about their specific needs.

Cold email tips

Craft a short, relevant, and compelling subject line. For example, something like: “Need help with capacity in TX?“.
Always personalize the first line of the email. Make sure you reference their industry, business, or a shared connection.
Focus on exactly how you solve a specific problem, not just what you do.
End with a clear call-to-action (CTA) that keeps your communication lines open, like: “Would you be open to a 10-minute call next week?“.

6. Use multi-channel outreach

Shippers are constantly bombarded with outreach from brokers trying to convince them to use their services. So, if you rely on a single communication channel, they’re likely to ignore you.

As such, it’s best to mix it up with a multi-channel approach. This could look something like:

Day 1: Cold call and a follow-up email.
Day 3: LinkedIn message and a comment on a post.
Day 5: Follow-up email with new, valuable insights related to the freight industry.
Day 10: Second call or voicemail.

7. Focus on value

Brokers often wrongly assume that shippers are only focused on ways to reduce costs. Of course, this is important, but leading with rates is a mistake. The truth is, there will always be a cheaper broker out there.

Instead, you should lead with the value you can provide. This means highlighting common problems like volume spikes or short-notice loads, and telling the shipper how you can solve them.

If you have existing clients, you can back up your claims with testimonials and case studies that demonstrate how you’ve addressed these issues in the past.

8. Pay attention to timing and frequency

When it comes to the sales process, timing is important every step of the way. Naturally, this means that when and how often you reach out make a big difference.

There is no one-size-fits-all approach in terms of timing, but generally, it’s best to reach out on Tuesdays and Thursdays between 10 am and 12 pm and between 2 pm and 5 pm.

It’s also a good idea to avoid contacting shippers on Mondays as they’re catching up with lots of messages they received over the weekend, and Fridays when their focus shifts toward concluding the workweek.

The frequency of your outreach is also crucial. Simply put, a single voicemail isn’t enough. Consistency is key, so set up automated reminders for follow-up calls and emails.

9. Track performance and improve

Tracking the performance of your prospecting efforts helps you identify any underperforming areas that need to be improved. You can analyze the success of your outreach by monitoring metrics like:

Number of calls and emails per day.
Response rates.
Conversion rate to shippers.
Appointments booked.
Average time from first contact to first load.

Always look for patterns in the data. If you notice your emails are underperforming, tweak the subject lines. Are you booking more loads from a specific niche? Concentrate your efforts there.

10. Position yourself as an expert

Shippers are contacted by multiple brokers each day with similar pitches. So, to stand out from your competitors, you need to become a knowledgeable and trusted voice. Make sure you stay up to date with:

The latest industry news from authoritative sources.
Updates to DAT and SONAR.
Information that affects the freight industry, like weather alerts, fuel price fluctuations, and port congestion.

When you’re armed with this knowledge, you can share insights with your prospects that position you as a credible expert. For instance, at the start of a call or email, you could say: “We’re seeing rates soften on the LA–Dallas lane, so it might be a good time to lock in volume.” This positions you as a trusted advisor, not just another broker.

Prospecting Mistakes All Freight Brokers Should Avoid

The freight sales process presents numerous challenges, and brokers frequently make several common prospecting errors. So, bear these errors in mind and make sure you avoid them:

Poor time management: Research is important, but don’t spend 30 minutes preparing for a single call. You’ll be making a lot of calls, so use your research time efficiently.
Spray-and-pray outreach: Don’t just send out a high volume of generic messages and hope for the best. Remember, personalizing your interactions is key.
Talking too much: When calling prospects, give them time to speak and ask questions. The last thing you want is to come across as pushy and overbearing.
Not following up: If you don’t use an automated system, it’s easy to forget about follow-ups. This is a big mistake as they’re essential for closing a deal.
Failing to track performance: If you don’t monitor your successes and failures, you’ll never be able to improve your outreach.

Avoiding these mistakes keeps your prospecting sharp, but training can take it further.

Learn How to Prospect with Online Freight Broker Training

To expand your knowledge of prospecting and develop comprehensive freight brokering skills, consider taking an online course. The 90-Day Freight Broker Course teaches you all you need to know about prospecting, and covers other important topics such as:

Identifying shipper niches.
Using load boards.
Setting up a freight brokerage.
An introduction to Transportation Law.
Managing invoices, payments, and cash flow.

For just $890, you get access to 100 hours of comprehensive content available in text, audio, and video. And if you’re unsatisfied, we’ll give you a full 30-day refund. Join the waitlist now to become a freight broker in 90 days or less!

Final Thoughts

Prospecting is a vital part of the freight sales process. If you approach it with the right mindset, strategy, and consistency, you can start turning cold leads into long-term partners.

Remember to stay focused, lead with value, and keep refining your approach. When you get the balance right, prospecting helps you build a lasting and profitable brokerage business.

FAQs

1. How long does it take to turn a prospect into a client?

The amount of time it takes to convert a prospect into a client varies widely and depends on numerous factors. Generally, it takes around 2-8 weeks. However, it can sometimes take months of follow-ups to turn a prospect into a paying customer. Remember, timing and persistence are key in successful conversions.

2. How many contacts should a freight broker contact per day?

Typically, freight brokers make between 50-100 outreach attempts per day. This includes outreach via various channels like calls, emails, and social media platforms. Yet, you should always focus on quality over quantity by targeting the right prospects with personalized messages.

3. How do I know when to stop pursuing a prospect?

If a prospect doesn’t respond after 8-12 touchpoints over a number of weeks, it’s best to take a pause. End with a polite message and circle back after a few weeks if you think the prospect is still worth pursuing.

Sources: